2025 marked a pivotal reset for Arizona real estate — especially for investors. Inventory climbed to multi-year highs, pricing flattened, operating costs surged, and underwriting discipline became the new competitive edge. It was also the first full year under major industry reforms: the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), new state-level housing initiatives, and the NAR settlement, which changed how compensation is disclosed and how buyers engage brokers. Against this backdrop, Arizona shifted into a more rational, opportunity-rich environment — especially for investors who watch the numbers and adapt early.
Big Picture: A Cooling, Rebalancing Market
Inventory & Supply
- 2025 saw a major increase in housing supply across Arizona. According to ResiClub, Arizona ranked #4 in the nation for inventory growth, with a +36% jump year-over-year in active listings.
- That shift reversed much of the pandemic-era inventory shortage, bringing supply back to pre-boom levels in many markets.
- In Phoenix and Maricopa County, active listings surged, giving buyers — and investors — more choices and negotiation power.
Sales Volume & Market Activity
- Despite higher inventory, sales volume held up reasonably well.
- That said, demand is cooling overall, particularly among first-time buyers and investors. Institutional buyers’ share has shrunk significantly.
- As of late 2025, typical “Days on Market” (DOM) across Arizona is about 70 days statewide, 63 days in Phoenix metro — markedly longer than 2023-2024.
Pricing: Stabilization, Modest Softening
- The median home price in Phoenix-Mesa-Scottsdale climbed modestly to ~$477,000 in mid-2025 — a ~2.7% YoY increase.
- Other data show a bit of downward pressure elsewhere
- Price per square foot remains relatively stable, especially in the condo and townhouse segments, while some of the mid-market single-family homes have seen price cuts or reductions of list price.
- The luxury segment — cash buyers, high-net-worth individuals — continues to outperform, buoyed by strong demand in enclaves like Paradise Valley, Scottsdale, Silverleaf, and other prestige suburbs.
What This Means for Investors
For savvy investors, 2025 presented a more balanced playing field compared to the overheated “seller’s market” of 2020–2022: more inventory means more selection; price cuts and longer market times give negotiating leverage; and luxury markets remain resilient.
However, the drop in institutional investor activity signals that competition is easing — but so is frothy demand, especially in the mid-market.
Headwinds & Cost Pressures: Insurance, Taxes & Hidden Expenses
Homeowners Insurance: A Silent Killer for Cash Flow
- Homeowners insurance rates in Arizona have surged by roughly 70% since 2019, putting the state among the fastest-rising markets for insurance costs nationwide.
- In 2025 alone, rates rose another ~13%.
- That increase isn’t just theoretical — many landlords and investors are seeing meaningful hits to cash flow.
- Some of the spike is driven by climate-related risk (wildfires, extreme weather, rising rebuild costs).
Property Taxes & Assessment Growth
- While Proposition 117 limits year-over-year increases in limited property values, assessed values (especially with new construction, annexation, or centrally valued properties) continue to rise — meaning effective tax bills may climb even more.
- Additionally, fire-district levies — often overlooked — are climbing. Some fire district NAVs rose ~6.6% in FY2025, which feeds into higher tax bills for affected properties.
Hidden Carrying Costs & Maintenance Overheads
- According to a 2025 Bankrate study, Arizona homeowners on average spend about $21,211 per year on “hidden” homeownership costs (insurance, utilities, maintenance).
- Investors need to factor in these rising carrying costs when modeling cash flow, especially on rentals — what might look like a good cap rate on paper can be eroded by higher insurance, taxes, and maintenance needs.
Growing Risk from Climate, Insurance Pullbacks, and Disruptive Events
- Rising wildfire risk, increased frequency of extreme weather events (hail, monsoons, heat stress, etc.), and rising rebuild costs are causing insurers to raise premiums — and in some cases exit certain markets altogether.
- This creates long-term uncertainty for landlords and investors: rising insurance costs, potential non-renewals, and increased underwriting scrutiny.
The NAR Settlement — Did It Matter for Investors?
1. No measurable pricing impact
Despite media coverage, investor acquisitions in Phoenix were not meaningfully affected by the NAR settlement or compensation rule changes.
Why? Because investors:
- already negotiate their representation explicitly
- already expect transparent compensation structures
- often work with the same broker across multiple deals
There was no meaningful change in cap rates, DOM, or discount patterns tied to the settlement.
2. Listing agents continued offering compensation
Despite the rule change, the majority of Arizona closings in 2025 still showed buyer-agent compensation, just through alternative disclosure channels.
This kept investor workflows unchanged.
3. The change appears mostly administrative
Investors mainly experienced:
- updated representation agreements
- more explicit buyer-broker conversations
- revised offer paperwork
No cost shift. No competitive shift. No deal-flow shift.
4. Institutional buyers were entirely unaffected
REITs and SFR aggregators negotiated compensation directly with brokerages long before the settlement.
Their slowdown in 2025 was due to:
- higher insurance
- rising taxes
- slower rent growth
- increased inventory
—not NAR rule changes.
Bottom Line on NAR Settlement:
Investors felt almost no economic impact.
The changes were mostly procedural, not financial — and Arizona’s market fundamentals mattered far more.
Other Noteworthy Trends & Market Developments
- Smart-City, Zoning & Multifamily Momentum: Maricopa County’s 2025 zoning reforms have streamlined multifamily and mixed-use permitting — especially along transit corridors — accelerating approvals and increasing density potential. That’s a big positive for investors considering multifamily or build-to-rent (BTR) strategies.
- Luxury Market Holding Strong: While broader segments cooled slightly, luxury/luxury-plus properties (cash buyers, high net worth individuals) remained resilient. Demand stayed robust in Paradise Valley, Scottsdale, Silverleaf, and other premium markets.
- Greater Emphasis on Long-Term Value & Sustainability: Smart-city initiatives (EV-ready building codes, green-certified builds, energy- or water-efficient infrastructure) are increasingly influencing development, underwriting, and investment strategy — especially for long-term holders.
What This Means for 2026: Investor Takeaways & Strategies
For investors focused on Arizona, especially in the Phoenix–Mesa–Scottsdale metro, 2026 is shaping up to be a “buyer’s market light.” The tailwinds and headwinds are both real — but if you position correctly, there’s opportunity.
What to watch / what to do:
- Lean into selectivity & underwriting discipline: With more inventory and rising carrying costs, underwriting needs to be conservative; model for higher insurance, taxes, and maintenance.
- Favor rentals with built-in resilience: Multifamily, build-to-rent (especially along transit corridors, where zoning reforms support density) may offer better long-term returns than single-family rentals, given ongoing cost pressures.
- Consider premium and luxury assets for stability: High-end cash-flow may be thinner, but luxury properties remain a hedge against volatility and often enjoy stronger demand from affluent buyers, especially out-of-state buyers seeking Arizona’s climate and tax advantages.
- Monitor insurance risk and market access: Given rising insurance costs (and potential non-renewals in wildfire-prone areas), focus on insured risk, maintenance reserves, and avoid over-leveraging in marginal areas.
- Leverage zoning and regulatory shifts: The new zoning reforms and smart-city initiatives may offer value-add or repositioning opportunities — especially for multifamily, mixed-use, or green-certified builds.
Final Thoughts
2025 was, for Arizona real estate, a transition year — from the unsustainably hot seller’s market of 2020–2022 toward a more balanced, mature landscape. For investors, that means both opportunity and risk: inventory and price corrections create buying windows, while rising carrying costs (insurance, taxes, maintenance) demand careful underwriting and long-term discipline.
If you’re evaluating your next acquisition — single-family rentals, multifamily, or even luxury assets — the next 12–18 months will likely reward those who are strategic, data-driven, and oriented toward long-term value rather than short-term flips.
DTD Realty — Do The Deal.
Driven. Trusted. Dependable.
📞 602.702.3601
🌐 https://www.dtdrealty.com
📩 [email protected]
